If you're in Orange County (NY) and are looking for a contractor for improvements to your home, look no further than Fair and Square Home Improvement.  In the six years since Erik and his company completed a complete remodel of our master bathroom - including a custom shower - my wife and I have also trusted him to remodel another bathroom, finish our room over the garage and last year install a beautiful custom fireplace. The quality of Erik's work has always been excellent.  And, I most appreciate the honesty and integrity he demonstrates throughout the process.  Unlike many contractors who promise much and deliver little - or at least little on time - Erik meets deadlines and commitments. If he says it will be done you can bank on it! Fair has Square has done framing, plumbing, tile, light electrical and finish work in our home.  And, Erik's local contacts enable him to refer you to the best, most reliable contractors in the area, including a painting contractor who has no local equal. While we don't currently have home improvement plans, we will most certainly be calling on Fair and Square when we do Over the past several years I've had occasion to recommend Erik's services to no fewer than 12 family and friends - much to their satisfaction. Call Fair and Square.  You'll be glad you did.

Jim H.
Westtown, NY


If you are in need of a home improvement company, then look no further than Fair&Square. I have used them for multiple projects in my 2 homes over the past 10 years with wonderful results.I had my kitchen remodeled and 2 complete bathroom renovations-all have turned out beautifully. Owner Erik Mahany is one of the nicest,most trust worthy business owners I have ever come in contact with. No un-returned phone phone calls or not showing up when scheduled.He is always there when planned with all projects finished on time. He takes pride in his work and is always focused on a happy customer. I would never use any one else.


Rosanne C.

Washingtonville N.Y.

Recently we had a composite deck and railings put on our home. Fair and Square did an awesome job and we are so pleased with their work. This is not the first time we have used Fair and Square and will certainly continue to use them for all our home improvements. Fair and Square is by far one of the most reputable Home Improvement companies in Orange County New York, not to mention the price is always right as well.


John O.

Westtown, New York

Fair and Square performed magic with their basement remodel after my basement was destroyed by a flood. They were professional, talented, reliable and did a fantastic job!! I would recommend them for any home or business remodel!


Mary D.

Orange County N.Y.

Fair and Square Home Improvement did an amazing job on our finished basement. We have a beautiful mahogany custom built bar, full bath, separate storage area with built in shelves and a custom ski tuning work shop! We were very pleased and would definitely recommend Fair and Square Home Improvement for your next remodeling project!


Anne and John K.

Scranton, PA


My wife and I were on the fence for almost a year about whether we would proceed with a basement remodel in our home in Warwick, NY.    In addition to all the normal work that would be needed, we also would have to add an egress window to keep to local code.   After receiving several quotes from local contractors that were close to $40,000, we pretty much decided that the project would not happen.    

    We were then referred to Erik Mahany of Fair and Square by a local contractor who was doing some work on another room in the house.   He heard some of the issues we were facing with the basement project and said we had to call Erik and have him come by.   From the first time we met, not only could you tell Erik knew the business of remodeling inside and out, you also could tell you were dealing with someone of character and who cares about his work.       Not only did Erik come back with a price we could not refuse to move forward with but his price including things that the others did not (i.e. crown molding, air ventilation system,etc).   

    Erik and his team were always on time and were very considerate to my entire family.     As the project continued, Erik also made some additional recommendations that were not apparent when the project started but added not only value to the house and project but also security in our investment (we added a 220V electrical outlet to the outside for connection to a back-up generator system).   

     We have some projects that we plan on doing in the next year or so and there will be no one else we call but Erik and Fair and Square.  Please make sure you give him a shot on any project yo have.   You will not be disappointed.     Thanks for everything Erik.  


Christopher P.

Warwick, NY



(845) 820-3027

© 2023 by THE BUILDER. Proudly created with Wix.com